Lighthouse 47 – A Happy Ending for Abused Animals

Animal Rescue in Erie, PA

One of the largest animal abuse cases in recent history was discovered in 2021 on Lighthouse Street in Erie, PA.

Diane Eggleston, the resident at Lighthouse Street, was discovered to be animal hoarding, keeping animals in unlivable conditions including small cages, stacked together in trash piles, with evidence showing they rarely had time outside.

Abused Animals in Erie, PA
Living Conditions for the Animals on Lighthouse Street in Erie, PA. Photo Credit: Bonsai's Cage, Erie Humane Society/Facebook.com

Due to the number of animals found for this rescue more than one rescue was needed to ensure the welfare of all the animals involved.  With living conditions as they were, the death toll was expected to be high, but luckily that’s not what happened.

“There were 47 animals seized from the house,” said Lisa Stiles, Chief Humane Officer of the Erie Animal Cruelty Division. “Unfortunately, one was deceased upon removal from the home, so that’s why it was 46 that we can say happily all found their homes.” [[1]]

After the rescue on May 25th, 2021, the gracious staff at Erie Humane Society took over their treatment. Many of them needed to be nursed back to health.

Not only were all the animals pulled out alive from cruel conditions, but nearly all of them found new homes – all but one. That is why the Erie Humane Society lovingly refers to them as the “Lighthouse 47.”

A Happy Ending for the Animals of Lighthouse Street

Rescued Pup in Erie, PA
Corneila happy to be stretching her legs and socializing in the courtyard at the shelter. Photo Credit: Erie Humane Society/Facebook.com

You can see the dramatic change in the lives of these animals just from the photos in the above Facebook post shared by the Erie Humane Society Animal Cruelty Division.

In addition, a few success stories have been shared by the owners of the pets' new homes.

One of these comes from Mike Cain who adopted Birch from the rescue, a pup who now lives a good life on a farm. “He’s just happy,” said Cain during an interview with JET 24. “We got another dog, and he just loves being with people, and he listens well. He’s just a real pleasurable dog to have.”

Debra Wolfram also adopted a cat from the Lighthouse rescue named Rose. She has white fur that is lustrous and beautiful today, but it wasn’t always that way for her.

“My heart was broken,” Debra said. “It really was. To know that someone could do that to an animal, I mean, they’re your kids.”  Rose is now living and very much enjoying the city life in her new home.

Due to the conditions, some of the rescued animals had a longer road to recovery than others, which caused them to stay in treatment longer with the Erie Humane Society. Shirley was the final cat to be adopted. She joined her new forever home on February 19, 2022. [[2]]

This rescue was one of the region’s best success stories for animal enforcement officers.

What Happened to Diane Eggleston?

The warrant obtained for Eggleston’s arrest was obtained by cruelty officers and executed with the help of the Erie Police Department. Diane Eggleston was charged with almost 90 summary offenses and a handful of felonies for her actions that resulted in animal cruelty. [[3]]

Although she was charged with multiple felonies and nearly 90 summary motions, she pled guilty to four summaries and two misdemeanor counts.

The court told Eggleston to pay about $2,000 in court fees and fines. She was ordered to not own any animals as a condition of her probation, which was set at nearly four years.

Animal Abuse & Hoarding Awareness- What to Look Out For

Animal hoarding is a severe issue for pets and people. It’s a complex issue where a generic intervention isn’t always possible. That’s why it is essential to watch for the signs that indicate someone could be taking these actions with pets. [[4]]

  • The person doesn’t know how many animals are under their care.
  • Their home has deteriorated conditions, including broken furniture, holes in the wall, and clutter.
  • The animals are lethargic, emaciated, and filthy.
  • Fleas and vermin could be present in the home or around the property.
  • The individual insists that their animals are healthy and happy even when displaying clear signs of distress.

Not everyone with multiple pets at home is an animal hoarder. About 250,000 animals fall victim to hoarding behaviors, and this activity is covered under the cruelty statutes of every state.

If you suspect this problem exists in your community, reach out to your local animal enforcement officials or law enforcement. You could help to save the lives of animals, just like this heroic rescue story of Lighthouse 47.

[[1]] https://www.yourerie.com/news/local-news/over-90-charges-filed-in-lighthouse-street-animal-cruelty-case/ ; [[2]] https://www.yourerie.com/news/local-news/erie-humane-society-animal-cruelty-officers-return-to-site-of-one-of-the-largest-local-animal-cruelty-cases-in-recent-memory/ ; [[3]]https://www.pahomepage.com/news/large-animal-abuse-case-results-in-happy-ending-for-all-animals/ ; [[4]] https://www.yourerie.com/news/local-news/final-animal-from-lighthouse-street-cruelty-case-adopted/ ; [[5]] https://www.aspca.org/helping-people-pets/animal-hoarding